At the Smart Cities Council we're bullish on the benefits of using data analytics to drive better outcomes for cities and their residents. In fact, whole sections of our website are focused on data management and analytics and our new Smart Cities Readiness Guide offers volumes of expert advice and case studies on implementing advanced analytics throughout a city's infrastructure.
So we were curious about a new report titled Geek Cities: How Smarter Use of Data and Evidence Can Improve Lives. From Results for America, an initiative of America Achieves, and the Bridgespan Group, it outlines "how cities are building evidence about the most effective and efficient practices, policies and programs; investing limited taxpayer dollars in programs that demonstrate they work; and directing funds away from those that consistently fail to achieve measurable outcomes."
No argument there. But we do take issue with a comment from Michele Jolin, the managing partner and founder of the Results for America initiative who states: "Today ‘geeks’ are driving the competitiveness and dynamism of our nation's economy, and using creativity and data to transform society."
That's not quite right. From our vantage point, the cities that are making the most progress are ones that are working collaboratively by pulling in people from departments all across city hall -- and even from outside city hall -- to brainstorm and innovate and imagine what could be and then make it happen. Geeks – aka the IT department – are an important player but not the only one.
Geek cities? We'll stick with smart cities. But what do you think? Are we off base? Use the Comment section at the bottom of this article to share your thoughts.
And you can read more about the report, including the six cities it spotlights as at the forefront of the data and evidence movement -- Baltimore, Denver, Miami, New York, Providence and San Antonio – in the press release below.
New Study Shows How “Geek Cities” Are Improving Lives Nationwide
Results for America and The Bridgespan Group Release “Geek Cities: How Smarter Use of Data and Evidence Can Improve Lives”
Washington DC (PRWEB) November 14, 2013
Results for America, an initiative of America Achieves, and The Bridgespan Group released a new paper today highlighting the nation's best cities at using data and evidence to get better results for their citizens. Called “Geek Cities: How Smarter Use of Data and Evidence Can Improve Lives,” the paper reports on the data and results revolution taking place in local governments and analyzes how these handful of city leaders are radically transforming their city services by embracing "geeky" analysis of hard data and evidence to drive results.
Authored by Laura Lanzerotti, Jeff Bradach, Stephanie Sud and Henry Barmeier, the paper outlines how cities are building evidence about the most effective and efficient practices, policies and programs; investing limited taxpayer dollars in programs that demonstrate they work; and directing funds away from those that consistently fail to achieve measurable outcomes.
Based on extensive new research and a compilation of 45 interviews with leaders from America’s most innovative cities, the paper details how cities are using data and evidence to improve the lives of residents. The paper holds up six “Geek Cities” as examples worth emulating – those on the forefront of using data and evidence to improve outcomes and communities. The Geek Cities are: Baltimore, Denver, Miami, New York, Providence and San Antonio. These six cities are setting the trends for how data and evidence are being used to increase efficiency, focus on programs that are achieving results and steer resources away from those programs that are not succeeding. The Geek Cities are leading the way, compiling an evidence base and setting a standard for use of data on issues including education, jobs, youth development and preventing infant mortality.
These cities are leading the way by investing in building evidence, using data and monitoring performance. They are comparing the level of evidence behind different programs and setting priorities and allocating funding based on that evidence. They are breaking down silos and experimenting and inventing their way out of problems.
Some of the winning examples include:
- Baltimore completely upended its budgeting process to implement one that is outcome-driven and focused on hard data and, as one example, is shifting resources towards evidence-based interventions to eliminate infant mortality.
- Denver embraced a data-driven approach to tracking and continuously improving its schools and is investing in an in-house “academy” to teach city employees how to innovate, measure performance and continuously track their data and improve results.
- Miami revamped its education system by honing in on school performance data and regularly tracking that data on each child.
- New York City chose to invest in data – trying out new methods of serving critical populations, but carefully tracking the success rates of each method. New York then made the tough decisions to shift dollars away from programs that – according to evidence and data – were failing to get results and towards programs with evidence of success.
- Providence brought together community leaders across the board for an evidence-driven, community-wide approach to helping children. Providence is also democratizing the data, making it accessible to the public.
- San Antonio used evidence to set city priorities and determine how best to invest limited public dollars in a way that would make the most difference for children and open up life-long opportunities.
On the release of the paper, America Achieves managing partner and founder of the Results for America initiative, Michele Jolin said, “Today, ‘geeks’ are driving the competitiveness and dynamism of our nation's economy, and using creativity and data to transform society. The ‘Geek Cities’ highlighted in this report remind us of the extent to which city governments have become the incubators of innovation and the drivers of results in America. While Washington, D.C. seems to be stuck in unending partisan gridlock, these trailblazing cities are using evidence and data to change lives and deliver real results for their citizens.”
“The case studies presented here demonstrate that this is no longer a do-gooder’s dream, but a real possibility. Cities can work smarter for their residents, and indeed, they must, as they tackle big challenges and opportunities. The six cities in our paper prove that geek is good – that blending rigor and data with a passion for results and change can move the needle on big problems,” said Bridgespan’s Jeff Bradach.
San Antonio Mayor Julian Castro writes in his foreword, “Cities like the ones featured in this report are innovating their way into the future, creating models that can be adapted across the nation. If smarter use of data and evidence to improve lies makes us geek cities, then all I can say is: Join us! Because what we need is more geek cities in every corner of the country.”
In his foreword introducing the paper, CEO of the Annie E. Casey Foundation Patrick McCarthy highlights the importance of the cities used in the study, and how philanthropy needs to be involved as well, saying, “Taken together, the examples highlighted in these pages tell us a great deal about what municipal leaders can do and can achieve when they make greater use of evidence and more skillful use of data. But this is not government’s role alone. Those of us in philanthropy have a key role to play here.”
The Bridgespan Group concludes the paper with directions for city leaders and their federal, state and philanthropic partners on how to improve outcomes based on their observations from the six city examples.
About Results for America Results for America, an initiative of America Achieves, works to improve outcomes for young people, their families and communities by helping drive government resources toward solutions that are using data and evidence to demonstrate results. In a climate of constrained resources and mounting demands, we know that public funds must increasingly be invested in “what works.” While much of the current public debate has focused on whether our nation should spend more or fewer resources, it is also critical to identify how to get better results from existing resources. Results for America wants to make “investing in what works” the new norm for allocating taxpayer dollars. Results for America has also recently launched a campaign to promote the use of evidence to improve outcomes at all levels of government called Moneyball for Government. For more on that effort, please visit https://moneyballforgov.com/.
About The Bridgespan Group The Bridgespan Group (https://www.bridgespan.org/) is a nonprofit advisor and resource for mission-driven organizations and philanthropists. We collaborate with social sector leaders to help scale impact, build leadership, advance philanthropic effectiveness and accelerate learning. We work on issues related to society’s most important challenges in three primary areas: pathways to opportunity for disadvantaged populations, environmental sustainability, and civic engagement. Our services include strategy consulting, executive search, and leadership development, philanthropy advising, and developing and sharing practical insights.